Federal agencies Leadership

President Trump nominates Scott Mugno to head OSHA

Scott Mugno
Photo: FedEx

Washington – President Donald Trump on Oct. 27 nominated Scott Mugno, vice president of safety, sustainability and vehicle maintenance at FedEx Ground, to lead OSHA as the assistant secretary of labor.

If confirmed, Mugno would take over from Loren Sweatt, who has served as acting assistant secretary of labor since July 24. Sweatt is the agency’s deputy assistant secretary of labor and President Trump’s first OSHA appointee.

Mugno has worked at FedEx since August 1994, joining the company as a senior attorney. From February 2000 to December 2011, he was managing director of corporate safety, health and fire prevention until his promotion to vice president.

In his most recent role at FedEx, Mugno was in charge of “developing, promoting and facilitating the safety and health program and culture,” a press release from the White House states.

Sweatt’s predecessor, Jordan Barab, on his "Confined Space" blog, wrote that “Mugno is clearly knowledgeable about safety and health, although he has a few upsetting notions.”

Barab points to a 2006 article in Business Insurance that reported on an event at which Mugno, the current OSHA subcommittee chairman of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce’s Labor Relations Committee, said, “We’ve got to free OSHA from its own statutory and regulatory handcuffs.” The report also notes that Mugno said some of the agency’s regulations should have a fixed time period until discontinuation – known as sunset provisions. The Chamber of Commerce is a noted regulatory opponent and filed suit against OSHA’s Improve Tracking of Workplace Injuries and Illnesses final rule in January.

“There is currently nothing in the law that allows standards to be sunsetted, unless OSHA goes through a regulatory process determining whether they are still needed or not,” Barab wrote.

Mugno also has served on a number of American Trucking Associations committees and is the chairman of the American Transportation Research Institute’s Research Advisory Committee. ATA congratulated Mugno on his nomination in an Oct. 27 press release. “Scott is a very familiar face to ATA, having been a longtime and active member in our organization,” ATA President and CEO Chris Spear said in the release. “Throughout that whole time, he has been a strong and committed voice for safety and responsibility. He is an outstanding choice to lead OSHA, and I look forward to working with him after his swift confirmation.”

Advocacy group National Council for Occupational Safety and Health urged a “rigorous and thorough” review of Mugno’s nomination in an Oct. 30 press release. Mugno’s next formal chance to meet senators likely will come when he appears before the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee. At press time, no hearing had been scheduled.

The HELP Committee then would vote on sending Mugno’s nomination to the full Senate for confirmation. Sen. Patty Murray (D-WA), ranking member of the HELP Committee, said she wants to know how Mugno will protect workers.

“Given President Trump’s unrelenting commitment to undermining worker protections and making it easier for corporations to take advantage of workers, it is critical that OSHA remains committed to enforcing health and safety standards – and punishing corporations who put their employees’ lives at risk,” Murray said in an Oct. 31 press release. “Mr. Mugno has spent his career working for big business, so I look forward to hearing how he plans to stand up for workers and continue OSHA’s active role in deterring corporations from endangering workers’ health and safety.”

Post a comment to this article

Safety+Health welcomes comments that promote respectful dialogue. Please stay on topic. Comments that contain personal attacks, profanity or abusive language – or those aggressively promoting products or services – will be removed. We reserve the right to determine which comments violate our comment policy. (Anonymous comments are welcome; merely skip the “name” field in the comment box. An email address is required but will not be included with your comment.)

Title

Ronald Odell
November 3, 2017
I look forward to Mr. Mugno's confirmation. I believe that his experience will serve to not only continue, but to improve the work of OSHA. I believe that Sen. Patty Murray's comments were uncalled for and totally political. Any corporation or business is best served when it values it's employees and does all it can to insure their safety and health.

Title

Renea Nordquist
November 3, 2017
I am truly disappointed that this article would include the last quote of Senator Patty Murray (D-WA) in the article. I believe a person can want deregulation and still be committed to worker safety and health. Common sense and our inner sense of well being needs to instilled in everyone's mindset- not that Employer's should wrap the employees in bubble wrap and let no harm come to them.

Title

Allen Walker
November 3, 2017
It sounds like Mr. Mugno will be a committed force for worker safety. It is sad that this article attempts to paint him in a bad light using partisan rhetoric to negatively sway people's opinions. I continue to see a negative bias in any article that pertains to the current administration when there is no real track record to prove any of the assertions. Such as this quote which says "Trump has an unrelenting commitment to undermine worker protections". Yet there is no factual basis for that comment and it does not belong in an article that is meant to inform of a new appointee. If this were an editorial then it would be appropriate. Please work to discontinue this type of junk reporting.

Title

Bob H.
November 3, 2017
I like the others who have commented look forward to Mr. Mugno's confirmation. Like the previous folks said, I am disappointed with the political rhetoric comment on undermining workers safety. As a professional of 20 + years for various industries and companies along with different political views over those years, that comment is uncalled for. It has been proven the Bufford Pussor Walking Tall approach to seeking compliance for work when over done doesn't work!!!! As the previous history of raising penalty cost and telling folks to go out for compliance audits you haven't seen marked improvements in safety. When great improvement are made is in team events and engagement and recognition for all. In my opinion, voluntary programs like "VPP" are the way to go. Simply put, bad health, safety, and environmental is not good for your team of employees and it definitely does not make good business sense. I have work in Chemical, Medical, and distribution industries. These industries know what their dangers are. If anything thing these industries tend to be type "A" in their approach. In my career we tend to go above and beyond what "OSHA" said because it was the right thing to do and it made good business sense. So please report the facts and don't try to put a political spin on my views. Allow us the reader to make our judgment based on those facts in how we want to view the selection as good or bad.

Title

B. Van Buskirk
November 3, 2017
It would be beneficial to the national safety program to have an invidual with an extensive background in safety management. Nice having a legal knowledge, but better having experience as a “safety professional”.

Title

John W.
November 3, 2017
I fail to believe the Safety Director for a company that consistently under reports injuries and illness via OSHA 300 / 300A forms is the best candidate to lead the Occupational Safety and Health Administration. Mr. Mugno has no education in Safety and Health or Industrial Hygiene. He is a lawyer, he knows how to work around OSHA laws and contest penalties sure but please, give me a break, he is as qualified to be head of OSHA as Trump is to be president. Leading OSHA is about putting workers health and safety interest first and making policy and regulation that upholds this principle. Worker advocacy should be at the heart of osha not industry advocacy...that job belongs with the chamber of commerce. Mugno's nomination is the result of bamboozled trump supporters in the labor industry who voted against their own best interest, so sad.

Title

Dan S
November 6, 2017
Too much labor lobby controlling NSC perspectives. This article is a clear example of bias reporting by politically motivated staff writers.

Title

Robert M
November 19, 2017
So, after reading this article, I visited FedEx safety websites and their accident record. FedEx seems to have a proactive driver safety programs, strongly embracing rules to curb distracted driving, driver fatigue, etc. However, their accident record is not very good. And in fact, as you watch FedEx drivers speed down the road, reading addresses from their handheld delivery device, and delivering well after dark, you can only wonder if FedEx safety policies are written to hang their drivers out because it doesn't seem to match up with their publicly visible business plan. If Mr. Mugno's goal really is to get rid of "bothersome" safety regulations, then I hope the Senate Committee digs in to make him specifically identify how his clean up is going to protect and improve worker safety. There continues to be 4,800 workers killed per year (13 per day). That should not be acceptable to Mr. Mugno.

Title

Gary Brent
November 29, 2017
My name is Gary Brent . I was employed by FedEx Express for 19 years, and in my 20th year I was fired for being a Whistleblower. People that believe everything they hear about FedEx is nothing but fantasy. FedEx is a company that does NOT follow U.S. laws, FAA, FMCSA Regs.,Osha, EEOC. Regs., State Laws. Look at websight, Federal Contractor Misconduct Database /FedEx and you will be suprised how may fines FedEx has paid the US Government for misconduct. You can check any company by putting their name in FCMDB, you be astonished. Check online FedEx Asbestoes Poisoning in Puerto Rico 2014, and then ask yourself if FedEx is a company that cares about the environment and people? I sent letters to Scott Mugno when he was at FedEx as VP of Safety, Health, and Fire Prevention , about serious vehicle issues, he never answered my letters. I recorded pictures of FedEx Ground Trailers in 2012 which were in terrible mechanical condition. At this time Mr. Mugno was SR VP of Safety and Vehicle Maintenance at FedEx Ground. I am speaking as a former Airline Pilot, Flight Instructor, MEL/Instrument, Aircraft Dispatcher Part121,and US Coast Guard Merchant Marine Capt. At FedEx, I was a Tractor Trailer Driver Instructor and Safety Advocate; I have an extensive knowledge of OSHA, FAA, FMCSA,CFR Regulations. Scott Mugno is NOT qualified to be Asst. OSHA Director, my photo’s and documents will prove my allegations. FedEx and Scott Mungno are corrupt.

Title

Richard
March 26, 2020
Mr. Mugno, is all about deregulation of safety and health standards. Keep OSHA from entering your business. Appeal any and all penalties you may receive. As a safety professional he is NOT. His background is that of a lawyer who opposed new regulations not just in the transportation industry ie; fedex but General Industry Standards. I can speak having worked under his organizational department. Before getting terminated and denied benefits after being injured while performing duties for my job. He can talk a good game but there is no substance, just looks good from a distance like a mirage. We can do better then that for our workers in all industries. VERY SAD ! Gary Brent posting tells truth to power. Gary Tells it like it is.

Title

Frank Snitz
August 13, 2020
Mr. M is no Eulah Bingham, distinguished toxicologist appointed during Carter Administration. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eula_Bingham Of course, we know that DT Admin does not want acknowledged experts heading his agencies. They might administer in accordance to objective reasons related to the Public Good. Can't have that when the raison d'etre is to run environmental and health agencies to the ground.