NSC Business and Industry Division news NSC Construction and Utilities Division news NSC Labor Division news Federal agencies Fines/penalties

$50,000 minimum: House committee proposes significant hikes to OSHA fines

Fine seal
Photo: Waldemarus/iStockphoto

Washington — The House Education and Labor Committee is proposing substantial increases to OSHA fines as part of the budget resolution for fiscal year 2022, which begins Oct. 1.

Approved Sept. 10, the committee’s portion of the Build Back Better Act seeks to raise OSHA’s minimum fine for willful or repeated violations to $50,000 from $9,753 and the maximum to $700,000 from $136,532.

“As part of the Build Back Better plan, workers’ rights are strengthened with provisions to apply civil monetary penalties for labor law violations and by updating the dollar amount of worker safety penalties so they are large enough to serve as an adequate deterrent,” Committee Chair Bobby Scott (D-VA) said in a Sept. 9 press release.

Serious and failure-to-abate violations would move to a maximum of $700,000 from $13,653. Fines for the latter violations are on a per-day basis.

In a separate release, Rep. Joe Wilson (R-SC) said Democrats “want to put private business out of business.”

 

He added: “For example, the Democrat [Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute] includes provisions that would hike monetary Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) penalties for private businesses by 512%.

“To be clear, committee Republicans do not condone employers that violate important labor laws, and we have always supported the authority of OSHA to hold bad actors accountable through enforcement and existing monetary penalties. But the Democrats’ proposals unnecessarily put a target on the backs of business owners to appease their big labor allies.”

The committee’s portion of the Build Back Better Act includes a proposal to give OSHA $707 million for enforcement, development of standards, whistleblower investigations, compliance assistance, State Plan funding and related activities. It also includes a proposal to provide $133 million to the Mine Safety and Health Administration.

Post a comment to this article

Safety+Health welcomes comments that promote respectful dialogue. Please stay on topic. Comments that contain personal attacks, profanity or abusive language – or those aggressively promoting products or services – will be removed. We reserve the right to determine which comments violate our comment policy. (Anonymous comments are welcome; merely skip the “name” field in the comment box. An email address is required but will not be included with your comment.)

Title

STAN GRAY
September 17, 2021
This would be the straw that broke the camels back for a small employer. Most would close their doors to avoid a fine like this. Most employers are unaware of new guidelines and must learn to ask for help thru OSHA or private safety consultants. The latter being very costly to small business. I know of no employer that would put his employees at risk. Looks like this is a attempt to throttle small business.

Title

Kris
September 17, 2021
These fines will put small businesses out of business. There needs to be a provision to protect small businesses. I believe fines should increase but not to that extent.

Title

TJ California
September 17, 2021
Our "state" has figured out how to run business off by taxing and onerous regulation......This action will run more business "offshore" thus doing exactly the opposite of what we need. What nutcases we have on the Potomic.....

Title

Matt
September 17, 2021
I can see raining fines, but seriously? OSHA can find anything wrong now, can you only imagine? Wish the Government would take other crimes in our country this serious.

Title

John
September 17, 2021
1) small businesses are not typically on OSHA's radar due to the fact that they won't ever get the money from a citation, and they have low numbers of employees 2) if a business, big or small, neglects their employees and puts them in harm's way, then they deserve to close 3) California is a state, no need for quotes 4) you all sound like scummy business owners who don't take accountability for your employees' health and safety

Title

Terry Fletcher
September 17, 2021
I could see repeat offenders having to deal with this. But to hike up rates like this will cripple business that may not have made the mistake or violation on purpose. This is insanity once again by Democrats

Title

Doug Sea
September 18, 2021
It is about time, the only thing that most employers care about is the money they make off the backs of their workers. Maybe if it costs more to harm their employees they will be more likely to invest in their employees safety.

Title

Name
September 19, 2021
EPA already has these level of fines. About time employers are held to the same level of endangering their employees as they have been for contaminating the earth. I always like to use this analogy. Currently if you make an employee go out in a boat on a lake to take a water sample and they tell you they can’t swim and need a life preserver, but you say to bad and don’t give them one. If they are out there doing the sampling and fall out of the boat drown. In the process they also spill a large can of gasoline in the water. OSHA will fine the employer $7K for the fatality and EPA will fine them in the 100 thousands. So, where do you think employers money is going?

Title

RW California
September 20, 2021
So in reply 1) In 30+ years of safety consulting, nearly all of my clients have been small businesses. Yes, OSHA does go after small businesses in a big way, even though the RIR for small businesses is 1.2 and large businesses is 3.5. 2) Few small businesses neglect their employees, especially in this job market. Few states have an independent employee act, so if an employee fails to follow company rules or use the supplied equipment properly, the company still has to pay the fines. If it is a multi-employer, such as a major construction project and the sub violates the rules, then the GC still pays the fine and has the deep pockets. 3) California should be in Quotes. This state does not fall under Fed OSHA, and their regulations under CalOSHA have still managed to allow 450 people a year to die on the job with a fatality rate of 2.5 4) Scummy Business owner here, as opposed to regulators who have never produced a dollar, only taken tax money from the workers who produce. This is a way to raise revenues and increased fines have never shown to produce reduced injuries.

Title

Big Huck
September 24, 2021
How about fining an employee that violates company rules and generates an osha encounter? Their goal is to punish employers not assist. How about some punishment for lawmakers and unelected bureaucrats. There is never any punishment for the members of the favored ruling class.

Title

Darin Perkins
October 4, 2021
Another joke of a proposal that will accomplish nothing except bring in more tax dollars (fines) into the government coffers so that our benevolent Congress can spend (waste) it.