On Research

The "On Research" blog has been discontinued, but Safety+Health now publishes Q&As with Journal of Safety Research contributors under that name.

Research to explore link between heavy lifting, detached retinas

March 2, 2015

It’s well known that lifting a heavy load can hurt the back.

However, researchers are exploring how lifting, pushing and pulling also can result in eye damage.

A four-year study funded by a $1.4 million grant from NIOSH will examine the connection between heavy physical activities and retinal detachment, which occurs when the retina pulls away from its nourishing layer of blood vessels, resulting in potential vision loss.

The team of a half-dozen researchers from the University of Massachusetts-Lowell and Reliant Medical Group in Worcester, MA, intend to gather data from 200 cases in a larger and more detailed study than 2008 research from the University of Bologna, Italy, that associated heavy occupational lifting with risk of retinal detachment.

Beyond trying to solidify the connection between material handling and the eye condition, the researchers also hope to provide recommendations that could better protect workers.

“If we are right, and this study confirms the initial observation, it would add another reason why industries in which there’s a lot of manual material handling may want to increase the introduction of lifting devices and automation,” David Kriebel, professor in the University of Massachusetts-Lowell’s Department of Work Environment, said in an interview with On Research.

Kriebel and his team are looking at how lifting leads to increases in pressure in the eye, and how that pressure may lead to retinal cells being torn from their capillary bed.

Trauma to the head, eye damage and a foreign body in the eye are known causes of retinal detachment, Kriebel said. His team is trying to nail down other causes.

“This is a very dangerous phenomenon,” Kriebel said. “The retinal cells for one reason or another are sort of unplugged. They get detached from their blood supply. Then they die. If that happens, you lose their light-detecting ability and you can lose eyesight.”

How it’s done

Kriebel previously taught in Italy, where he met Stefano Mattioli, lead author of the 2008 study that found “strong associations” of retinal detachment with eye surgery, eye or head trauma, severe near sightedness, heavy lifting and high body mass index. That study examined 61 cases of retinal detachment and 99 control cases.

“We decided it would be a good idea to follow up because one study doesn’t really prove anything. It could be just a chance finding, so it’s important to replicate,” Kriebel said. “Hopefully, we can improve upon his study and see whether it’s confirmed and whether the evidence gets stronger with a second study.”

Researchers plan to examine 200 insurance carriers of various occupational backgrounds from Reliant Medical Group. A questionnaire will ask participants about their job history and how much they lifted, pulled and pushed at those jobs.

Because participants might have difficulty remembering some of this information, the researchers will use a database called O*NET to link a job to the amount of lifting it requires. The database lists the mental and physical demands for thousands of jobs.

Researchers also will explore physical activity beyond work – participants will be asked how much they lift during their hobbies and housework.

Obesity another factor

Similar to the 2008 study, the research team will examine the link between obesity and retinal detachment.

“Obesity, like manual material handling, is something we know has a variety of health hazards associated with it,” Kriebel said. “If our study confirms this, it would add another disease to the list of negative health consequences of obesity.”

Post a comment to this article

Safety+Health welcomes comments that promote respectful dialogue. Please stay on topic. Comments that contain personal attacks, profanity or abusive language – or those aggressively promoting products or services – will be removed. We reserve the right to determine which comments violate our comment policy. (Anonymous comments are welcome; merely skip the “name” field in the comment box. An email address is required but will not be included with your comment.)

Title

Sheri Allen
July 26, 2016
Hi, this is exactly what's going on with me. In April 2015 I had retinal tears that came while I was at work lifting very heavy plates. (Worked in manufacturing plant) I didn't know what was going on at the time but I saw black floaters that I thought were flies, When I'd bat at them nothing was there, it also felt like something was in my eye. Late afternoon, my vision completely went black as if someone took a sharpie pen and colored my eye in so I couldn't see. I went to the E.R only to find out I had retinal tears and heavy bleeding going on. The retina specialist said it was good that I got there when I didn't it was close to detaching. They did laser surgery. I had reinforcement laser surgery in my left eye to help avoid the same thing happening to my left, since daily requirements of my job required 4,750lbs. of lifting per day. Wouldn't you know April 2016 (almost a year later) I was at work lifting heavy when I noticed the same thing going on, thinking it was my right eye and it turned out to be my left, when I stasrted seeing thr sharpie coloring in my eye. I left work went straight to my doctor and sure enough two retinal tears in my left eye. I tried to get W.C. since it happened at work and was denied. Last Thursday they terminated my job. I'm 52 years old, 22 years of service(perfect attendance and not late for work (shows on my yearly evaluations) and just like that, let go

Title

Jimmy Athon
January 11, 2017
Mister I am hearing what you're saying. Recently had a tear in my retina . I deliver newspapers for a living due to the fact that I bought into the illussion of being my own boss. I turned 60 in August and for the last twenty years I delivered newspapers and put up small directional signs for communities trying to sell their neighborhood homes. I dont do the heavy lifting , about 30 lbs at most , but it is a lot of lifting every day, that is 365 days a year without timeoff. I was stripped of half my route when my retina gave way and the carriers that rushed to my aid had difficulty doing what i had been doing alone , yes I was punished fo what others could not do, There are too many astroholes in business that jump to show how how they are ruthless in business management but couldnt do your job if there worthless life depended on it. I pray things work out for you man. As for me I went back to work for 23 days and the retina tore again, this time it was also lasered. Hoping that holds now, but lifting is everyday as is getting very little slepp , haven't heard any links to that but my eyes do get so tired sometimes. Hang in there brother better stuff will come from this.

Jimmy Athon
January 11, 2017
Sheri so sorry , I read your predicament forgot your gender but empathize totally. I should have said Ma'am I completely hear what you are saying. Hang in there woman , things will get better. God bless you.

Title

Sue
February 5, 2018
I had a question what if anyone could help. I recently was diagnosed with a retinal tear, my occupation is a tractor trailer driver. I don't unload the trucks or anything like that but I am concerned that some of the trailers that we have are up to 40,000 lb and as we arrive at our consignee we must drop the trailers which consists of cranking down landing gear and unhooking the Airlines and electric line. After that we then have to hook up to another trailer and crank the landing gear up. My concern and question is could all the stress of cranking that much weight everyday have caused a lot of pressure on my eye and perhaps cause the retinal tear. I would appreciate any buddies input on this please and thank you

Title

Michael Zachary
March 16, 2019
I just got a surgery for a retina detachment that I believed happened from pulling 2500 lbs. on a pallet jack at work yet the doctor says it did not happen there. I have an existing eye injury from 15 yrs. ago but pulled lots of weight over the years Had NO PROBLEM UNTIL I PULLED 2500 LBS.

Title

Antonio Nieto López
July 3, 2019
I had retinal detachment surgery in one eye two years ago, and then I had retinal detachment surgery in my other eye in September 2018. Is it safe for me to pick up heavy stuff, like suitcases when I´m going on holiday, or pushing furniture around? Thank you

Title

Name
August 3, 2019
This is a very informative as I work in the care industry,for 20 years in a care home.I have recently been diagnosed with retinal vein occlusion,I've controlled blood pressure for years 5.7colestral and very healthy otherwise A bit overweight. Also over the 60years,

Title

Name
January 19, 2020
Is a terrible fall as like down a flight of stairs a possible cause for a retinal tear?

Title

Kathogan
January 26, 2020
As a nurse for over 25+ yrs and I Just met a 60 ye old diabetic, who had bilateral retinal detachment from a heavy lift. He said the dr told him diabetes should not lift more 10 pounds. I’ve never hear this, or remember if I’ve been told.

Title

Shelsea
February 10, 2020
I am wondering about that as well, if a fall can cause a retinol detachment? I fell head first on a marble floor. My feet flew out in front of me landing on the floor head first. Location of impact was the back left of my head. Besides having neck issues and balance issues since, I also see double when reading much of the time.i was sent to an eye doctor. Two days after the exam I have floaters everywhere in my left eye, plus flashes of light in my peripheral vision in the same eye. I went back in and my eyes were dilated once more and I was told that my retina may end up detaching.

Shelsea
February 10, 2020
I also want to address Sheri Allen...... that I'm deeply sorry for her situation that she has had to deal with.

Title

Zafar Khalid
March 14, 2020
Manual material handling alone should not be considered. How about wrestling and rugby foot ball these two sports I have taken part.

Title

Charlotte
April 16, 2020
I’m a genius not a doctor. RDs occur bcuz you have/had a tear(s)/hole(s) in your retina. Usually a tear(s) & RD happy simultaneously. Hole(s) just develop but without trauma, the retina remains in place. Your optometrist should be checking annually. Any holes can then be lasered quickly and easily. It’s typically a large hole(s) that finally gives out and tears any other hole(s) can move a tiny bit & vitreous will flow thru pushing that part away as well. These things can happen to everyone at any time. I had 8 holes and 1 large one was tearing for about 4 months before I realized it. It was initially disturbed when I was hit by my airbag. The holes just developed. I was overdue for my exam but optometrist never checked anyway. I am partially blind in my eye bcuz of how it detached the first time and bcuz I waited too long to get it checked. It’s not a big deal. I’m happy I can see and I learned a lot to may help others. Oh a couple more things. I suggest trying the gas bubble first AND FOLLOW DIRECTIONS DOUBLE. If it detaches again get the Sclera Buckle- the one that wraps your entire eye. Get pain pills 5 days worth. I spoke a man in his late 60s. He had some type of freezing method done. He wished he hadn’t done it bcuz of the pain and it wasn’t working or something. Obviously these are based on my experiences.

Title

RJ
June 8, 2020
I recently had surgery for a small retinal tear in my left eye . This same eye had surgery for a a retinal tear 7 years ago. Both times I was digging clay soil and lifting loads of it as I planted bushes in my backyard. After the first surgery healed, I resumed my usual activities, which include yard work. I did not connect this type of activity as a possible reason for the tear as my father had a tear in the same eye at the same age as my first tear (54). I assumed it was genetics. Interesting to note, however, that my father was digging out a huge cactus in his yard when his retina detached. I am ashamed to admit I am overweight. Not huge, but need to lose some pounds. My father was not overweight. As a matter of fact, he was thin. Hope this info helps with your research. I am definately going to modify my physical activity from now on as I've had a lifetime of tending to lift heavy objects (such as bales of hay for horses ). I am a 62 year old woman, 5' 8", 185 lbs.

Title

donald becchetti
January 5, 2021
at age 77 I lifted the rear end of my snowmobile to get it ready for use. it was probably only 50 lbs. I, soon after, noticed a blank area in my vision. went to Dr. and was diagnosed with torn and detached retina. three days later had operation to reattach. so I believe moderate to heavy lifting can and did cause retina problems. DSB

Title

Julio
April 24, 2021
My brother is a good example. Furnishing office environment, including large glass wall panels, suffered from 3 detachments in both eyes at age 57.