Federal agencies Trucking Transportation

FMCSA to study impact of detention time on trucker safety

back-of-semi-truck
Photo: jmoor17/iStockphoto

Washington — The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration wants to study the safety impact of the time that truck drivers spend waiting for cargo to be loaded and unloaded.

That lag, often in excess of two hours, is known as “detention time.” In an Information Collection Request published Aug. 24, FMCSA states that “drivers who experience less detention time may be more likely to drive safely to reach their destinations within the [federal hours-of-service] limits and less likely to operate beyond HOS limits and improperly log their driving and duty time to make deliveries on time.”

The agency intends to collect data on driver detention time from about 80 motor carriers and 2,500 drivers – “representative of the major segments” of the trucking industry. FMCSA will then analyze that data to determine the frequency and severity of detention time and assess the “utility of existing intelligent transportation systems solutions” to measure detention time. A 2014 FMCSA study of detention time had “several limitations,” the notice states, including:

  • A small sample of mostly large carriers
  • A rudimentary estimation of detention time
  • An inability to identify time spent loading/unloading
  • Data that didn’t cover an entire 12-month period

“FMCSA needs additional data from a broader sample of carriers to understand the safety and operational impact of detention time, to better understand why detention time occurs, and to identify potential mitigation strategies the commercial motor vehicle industry may use to reduce detention time while improving operational efficiencies and safety,” the notice states.

Comments are due Oct. 23.

Post a comment to this article

Safety+Health welcomes comments that promote respectful dialogue. Please stay on topic. Comments that contain personal attacks, profanity or abusive language – or those aggressively promoting products or services – will be removed. We reserve the right to determine which comments violate our comment policy. (Anonymous comments are welcome; merely skip the “name” field in the comment box. An email address is required but will not be included with your comment.)

Title

Donna
September 2, 2023
Shipping and receiving need to have facilities while on detention sometimes in excess of 8 hours

Title

Sweet tarts
September 2, 2023
How the brokers they wait til last minute. To cancel loads and then they don't like paying Drivers detention time after Drivers half sit over three hours over they lie to Drivers and it just not right if wasn't for truck drivers the world would be hungry and lost with supplies and we drivers never get appreciated for being out here try make living for are families these companies treat us drivers very unappreciated thank for read God bless and they don't care about us

Title

Matt Eveland
September 2, 2023
It's funny to me that they are even looking in to this. The 14 Hour Logbook Rule mandates that you have 14 total hours from the time you start your log until you are done for the day plus with the implementation of the mandatory e-log systems being required in every truck, by every company with the very few exceptions of trucks too old for the e-log to work makes it hard to fake your log. Plus the e-log is tapped into the trucks engine computer that shows all the parameters of what it is doing in real time as well as the built in GPS tracking system that also shows the trucks location in real time. If the Shipper takes an excessive amount of time loading, then that load is going to be late and if the Consignee takes excessive time unloading then the next load for that truck may be delayed. That is why most companies give the Shipper and Consignee 2 hours to load or unload the truck before the trucking company starts charging them demerage time. "Big brother" has made it so he knows exactly where every truck is.

Title

Gary
September 4, 2023
Sea container hauler have the most detention time because the shipper and the customer are paying for the container .they often consider box as there own so the driver will have to wait .the customer and the shipping company are paying a rate for the container and not the drivers so wait times can go from a half hour to a all day driver have to sit and wait on duty not driving witch will take up driving time .some trucking company that pull containers will have the driver sign a off duty not in sleeper or the truck to save the drive time but the new regs the feds have put a stop to that . So yes detentio time is a hazard to drivers

Title

Steve Kuczynski
October 23, 2023
I am commenting on detention pay for truckers. As I sit here getting load I'm over my aloud time where I don't even know if the broker will be paying me for detention pay. Plus detention pay I is a step in the face cause 20 buck an hour doesn't cover any cost for truck, trailer over even my time. These shippers and recievers charge us drivers 200 plus to rework or even reschedule a load. So why shouldn't we get 200 buck an hour. Us truckers have more liability than these shippers and recievers. We should be getting paid for driver, truck and trailer PER HOUR. US truckers are not making money like these brokers, shippers or recievers. The ones suffering are us truckers. We need to be able to cover are cost and also make money to survive in this day and age. Plus don't sugar coat this. Plus safety is also bad cause then these shippers and recievers hold us up and expect us to run over are clock, and or try to deliver with not enough time to get to the destination. Thank you for your time. Don't let us down. We need action. I'm tired of running like a mad man and can't make money as a owner operator.